Question 1

What do all over 2023 TESLA MODEL Y models sell for?

Accepted Answer

Across 223 recorded sales of the 2023 TESLA MODEL Y with all over damage, the median was $9,500, from $4,800 to $13,800. That is 13% below the $10,900 median for the model across every damage type, over the last 36 months. Estimates from past sales, not a valuation.

Question 2

Was $12,500 a good price for this 2023 TESLA MODEL Y?

Accepted Answer

8492 comparable 2023 TESLA MODEL Y listings sold at auction for a median of $10,900, spanning $6,200 to $15,700. At $12,500 this one went 15% above that median. Auction prices reflect as-is condition, so the gap usually comes down to damage severity, mileage and whether the car runs.

Question 3

This TESLA MODEL Y sold without keys — does that matter?

Accepted Answer

Yes, usually. A missing key means the vehicle often cannot be started or moved under its own power at the yard, so its condition is harder to verify and buyers bid more cautiously. Replacing a modern key and reprogramming it to the immobiliser typically runs into the hundreds. It is one of the more common reasons an otherwise sound car sells below its comparables.

Question 4

How much below its undamaged value did this TESLA MODEL Y sell for?

Accepted Answer

The insurer put this 2023 TESLA MODEL Y's pre-damage retail value at $40,757. It sold for $12,500 — 69% below that. A gap this size is normal for auction vehicles: the buyer takes on the repair cost, the paperwork and the risk that damage is worse than the photos show.

Question 5

Is 36,460 miles high for a 2023 TESLA MODEL Y?

Accepted Answer

Comparable 2023 TESLA MODEL Y listings at auction averaged 38,302 miles across 8492 sales, so at 36,460 miles this one sits 5% below that. At salvage auctions mileage moves the price far less than damage does — a low-mileage car with structural damage will still sell under a higher-mileage clean one.

Question 6

What does a salvage title mean for this TESLA MODEL Y?

Accepted Answer

This 2023 TESLA MODEL Y was sold on a salvage title. A salvage title means an insurer declared the vehicle a total loss. Repairing it and passing a state inspection can convert it to a rebuilt title, which stays on the record permanently and affects resale value.

2023 TESLA MODEL Y BLACK - 7SAYGDEE1PA057927 | $12,500

Price

Auction service

Sale Date

Lot

Description

Similar Cars

Other TESLA MODEL Y listings

Other cars with all over damage

Popular models Tesla

Market Price Comparison - 2023 TESLA MODEL Y

How this 2023 TESLA MODEL Y compares

Frequently Asked Questions - 2023 TESLA MODEL Y